Public ESG rating disclosure

ESG Cert ESG rating: methodology disclosure

This disclosure is published under Article 23 and Annex III, point 1, of Regulation (EU) 2024/3005. Its contents follow the order required by Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/871.

Provider ESG Cert S.r.l. Methodology ESG Cert rating methodology Version 2026.7 · 17 November 2026

Contents

  1. Rating product
  2. Methodology
  3. Limitations
  4. Organisation
  5. Complaints and contact

1. Rating product

Annex III, point 1 (f), (g), (h), (i), (j), (o), (p)

1.1 Objective and materiality Annex III 1(f) · DR Art. 3(1)

ESG Cert's ESG rating expresses an opinion on the completeness of a company's answers about its environmental, social and governance profile and the documentation supporting them. It also assesses whether the company has substantiated actions to address its material ESG themes.

The company completes a single ESG questionnaire, attaches supporting documents and submits it. The assessment covers two axes:

  • Risk: the completeness of the answer to each ESG question and the documentation supporting it.
  • Mitigation: the presence of substantiated actions to address each material theme.

Double materiality

For each theme, the rating considers both the impacts generated by the company and the financial risks to which it is exposed:

  • Impact materiality: the extent to which the company's activities affect the theme, for example through energy consumption, emissions, waste, working conditions or its supply chain.
  • Financial materiality: the extent to which the theme affects the company's results, for example through climate hazards at its sites, water stress, exposure to regulatory risks, disruption involving staff or suppliers, or cyber incidents.

The two dimensions have equal weight (50% each). For each theme, a sector matrix based on the company's ATECO code assigns a materiality level to each dimension: High, Medium or Low. A theme is material when one dimension is High and the other is at least Medium. The matrix identifies 1 to 3 material themes per pillar, giving a total that ranges, in practice, from 3 to 8 of the 15 themes.

  • Unrecognised ATECO code: all 15 themes are proposed to avoid excluding potentially material themes.
  • Changes by the company: the company may add or remove themes. Each removal requires a written explanation, which ESG Cert reviews.
  • Confirmation at submission: the list of material themes is fixed when the questionnaire is submitted and can no longer be changed.

Materiality determines which themes are included on the mitigation axis. The risk axis includes one question for every theme, regardless of its materiality.

1.2 Factors and themes covered Annex III 1(g) · DR Art. 3(2)

ESG Cert combines the E, S and G factors into a single ESG rating, issued under Article 23(3) of Regulation (EU) 2024/3005. The results for the individual factors are reported alongside the rating; their respective weights are set out in section 1.3. The assessment covers 3 pillars and 15 themes:

PillarThemes
E (Environment)Energy & emissions · Climate risk & adaptation · Pollution · Water · Materials, circularity & waste · Biodiversity & land use
S (Social)Workforce & working conditions · Health & safety · Skills, diversity & equal opportunity · Human rights & value chain · Communities, consumers & users
G (Governance)ESG governance & management · Ethics, anti-corruption & integrity · Suppliers & payment practices · Operational resilience & cybersecurity

Each theme has a risk question and, if material, a mitigation question. Information about the company (sector, turnover, employees and sites for the reference year) defines the scope of the assessment but does not contribute to the allocation of points.

1.3 Weighting and aggregation Annex III 1(h)

Risk axis: 0–3 points per question

PointsCriteria
0Incomplete answer
1Answer based on self-declaration only
2Some of the required documents are present
3All required documents are present and have been processed

When a question requires no documents, the maximum available is 1 point. The absence of documentation that is not required neither penalises nor benefits the company.

Mitigation axis: 0–1 point per material theme

A material theme is awarded 1 point when all of the following conditions are met:

  1. The company declares actions relating to the theme.
  2. At least one action is Planned, In progress or Completed.
  3. The documentation required for the action's status is attached.
  4. The documentation has been processed.

Certifications. When a certification fully covers a theme, the assessment of that theme on the mitigation axis is considered complete and the corresponding question is not asked.

Aggregation

Result = (risk points earned + mitigation points earned) ÷ (risk points available + mitigation points available) × 100

The points from both axes are added together without applying further weights. The weight of each pillar and theme therefore corresponds to its share of the total points available to the company. This share depends on the documents required by the company's answers and the number of material themes.

Weight of the E, S and G factors

PillarThemesRisk points availableMitigation points availableWeight in the rating
E (Environment)612–181–332–54%
S (Social)511–131–327–46%
G (Governance)45–91–314–32%
Total1528–403–8100%

For example, if the company's answers require all the documents and there are two material themes per pillar, the weights are E 43.5%, S 32.6% and G 23.9%. In general, mitigation accounts for around 7–22% of the total. The ranges shown are based on the material themes proposed by the sector matrix and may vary if the company adds or removes themes.

Weight of each theme

PillarThemeRisk questionMitigation, if material
EEnergy & emissions31
EClimate risk & adaptation31
EPollution1 or 31
EWater1 or 31
EMaterials, circularity & waste1 or 31
EBiodiversity & land use31
SWorkforce & working conditions31
SHealth & safety31
SSkills, diversity & equal opportunity31
SHuman rights & value chain11
SCommunities, consumers & users1 or 31
GESG governance & management31
GEthics, anti-corruption & integrity1 or 31
GSuppliers & payment practices11
GOperational resilience & cybersecurity1 or 31

"1 or 3" means that the question has a maximum of 3 points when the company's answers require a document (for example, an environmental permit for the Pollution theme) and 1 point otherwise. With a total of 31 to 48 points available, each theme accounts for between 2% and 13% of the rating.

1.4 Themes and correspondence with the ESRS Annex III 1(i)

The table below shows the main correspondence between the 15 themes listed in section 1.2 and the topics in the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (ESRS):

ThemeMain ESRS correspondence
Energy & emissionsE1 Climate change (mitigation, energy)
Climate risk & adaptationE1 Climate change (adaptation)
PollutionE2 Pollution
WaterE3 Water and marine resources
Materials, circularity & wasteE5 Resource use and circular economy
Biodiversity & land useE4 Biodiversity and ecosystems
Workforce & working conditionsS1 Own workforce (working conditions)
Health & safetyS1 Own workforce (health and safety)
Skills, diversity & equal opportunityS1 Own workforce (equal treatment and opportunities for all)
Human rights & value chainS2 Workers in the value chain
Communities, consumers & usersS3 Affected communities · S4 Consumers and end-users
ESG governance & managementNo topical standard; ESRS 2 governance disclosures
Ethics, anti-corruption & integrityG1 Business conduct (corporate culture, corruption and bribery)
Suppliers & payment practicesG1 Business conduct (relationships with suppliers, payment practices)
Operational resilience & cybersecurityG1 Business conduct (operational resilience and cybersecurity)

The correspondence relates to the themes covered. It does not imply that the rating assesses every aspect addressed by the ESRS or verifies compliance with those standards.

1.5 Rating categories Annex III 1(j) · DR Art. 4(1)(e)

The points earned determine a result from 0 to 100, which is assigned to one of 10 rating classes, from AAA to D.

ClassResultLabel
AAA95–100Excellent
AA90 to below 95Very advanced
A85 to below 90Advanced
BBB75 to below 85Solid
BB65 to below 75Good
B55 to below 65Fair
CCC45 to below 55Adequate
CC35 to below 45Initial
C25 to below 35Weak
Dbelow 25Insufficient

How to read the scale. The result expresses the points earned by the company as a percentage of the total available (section 1.3). The class identifies the band in which that result falls. A higher class indicates more complete ESG answers and supporting documentation, together with greater coverage of material themes through substantiated actions. The class does not, in itself, measure the company's environmental or social performance.

Absolute value. The rating is expressed in absolute terms: the class reflects the company's result under this methodology, independently of the position of other companies. The rating contains no relative values.

1.6 Paris Agreement and international agreements Annex III 1(o)–(p) · DR Art. 3(3)

Environmental factor. The rating does not assess alignment with the objectives of the Paris Agreement or other international environmental agreements. Biodiversity screening uses proximity to Ramsar sites, designated under the Convention on Wetlands of International Importance (Ramsar, 1971), as one indicator of a site's environmental sensitivity.

Social and governance factors. The suppliers theme uses the ITUC Global Rights Index, which classifies countries according to their respect for internationally recognised workers' rights. The index is used to determine the share of supplies from high-risk countries. The rating does not assess alignment with international agreements such as the ILO conventions, the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights or the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises.

2. Methodology

Annex III, point 1 (a), (b), (c), (e), (k)

2.1 Methodology overview Annex III 1(a) · DR Art. 4(1)

Title
ESG Cert rating methodology
Version
2026.7, 17 November 2026
Rated companies
Companies registered in Italy, of any size and sector, identified by their main ATECO code
Validity
365 days from issue
Reference period
The year covered by the assessment, normally the company's last completed financial year

Process

  • Submission: the company completes the ESG questionnaire on the ESG Cert platform and submits it with the attached documents. ESG Cert fixes the data at the time of submission.
  • Issuance: an ESG Cert analyst checks the answers and documents submitted, then issues the rating, which is valid for 365 days.
  • Reproducibility: the rating is calculated exclusively from the data fixed at submission and can therefore be reproduced at any time. Once issued, it remains unchanged.

Backward- and forward-looking analysis

The analysis is primarily backward-looking: it is based on the company's data and documents for the reference year. Planned actions contribute to the mitigation axis only when supported by a document evidencing a decision, such as a resolution or a quotation. They therefore introduce a limited forward-looking element without making the rating a forecast.

Supporting models

  • The sector materiality matrix, which defines the impact and financial materiality of the 15 themes for each ATECO division.
  • The rules for awarding points on the risk and mitigation axes (section 1.3).
  • External screenings of water stress and each site's proximity to protected areas (section 2.3).
  • The list of countries at high risk for workers' rights, drawn from the ITUC Global Rights Index (section 2.3).
  • AI-assisted reading of uploaded documents to suggest values for the answers (section 2.5).

Key assumptions

  • The company's answers and documents are truthful and complete.
  • The main ATECO code represents the company's main activity.
  • The documents relate to the year covered by the assessment.
  • Missing data are not estimated: the absence of required documents reduces the points awarded to the answer.

Data quality and reliability

  • The source of each value is recorded: read directly from a document, derived from a document, calculated by ESG Cert, obtained from an external source or declared by the company.
  • Documents must cover the reference year.
  • The company confirms every value at submission. An ESG Cert analyst checks the answers and documents before the rating is issued.
  • The data are fixed at submission, allowing each rating to be reproduced from the same information.

Nature of the rating

Every rating includes the following statement:

«Il rating è un parere e non una misura di performance ambientale.»
(The rating is an opinion, not a measure of environmental performance.)

The rating is ESG Cert's opinion. It is not a credit rating, an investment recommendation, an audit or a guarantee of regulatory compliance.

2.2 Industry classification Annex III 1(b) · DR Art. 4(2)

Classification
ATECO 2025, the Italian classification of economic activities, aligned with NACE Rev. 2.1
Issuing body
ISTAT, Italian National Institute of Statistics
Documentation
istat.it/classificazione/documenti-ateco
Level used
Division (two digits) of the company's main activity

The company's ATECO code is taken from its Chamber of Commerce registry extract and can be corrected only if it does not reflect the company's actual main activity. The code determines which row of the sector materiality matrix is used. If it is not recognised, all 15 themes are proposed.

2.3 Data sources and processing Annex III 1(c) · DR Art. 4(3)

Sources

SourcePublic or non-publicUsed for
Answers to the ESG questionnaireNon-publicAll questions
Documents uploaded by the companyNon-publicDocumentation supporting answers and actions
WRI Aqueduct 4.0PublicWater stress at each site
Registers of protected areas: Natura 2000, Ramsar sites, EUAPPublicEach site's proximity to protected natural areas
ITUC Global Rights IndexPublicShare of supplies from countries at high risk for workers' rights

External screenings assign each site a low, medium or high level for the aspects assessed. A sustainability report published by the company, including a sustainability statement under the CSRD (Directive 2013/34/EU), is accepted as supporting documentation for the ESG governance and management theme. Disclosures under the SFDR (Regulation (EU) 2019/2088) are not used.

Three categories of documents

CategoryEffect on the rating
MandatoryWithout them, no rating is issued
If applicableRequired only according to the answer to a Yes/No question. A «No» answer is still recorded
OptionalStrengthen the documentation supporting an answer but do not affect the result

Certifications. Certifications held by the company are accepted as supporting documentation. If a certification fully covers a theme, the assessment of that theme on the mitigation axis is considered complete (section 1.3).

Missing data and updates

  • Estimation: ESG Cert does not estimate missing data or use substitute values (proxies). The absence of required documents reduces the points awarded to the answer.
  • Updates: the data remain as fixed at submission. They are updated when the rating is renewed after its 365-day validity period, through a new submission covering the new reference year.

Engagement with the rated company

  • The company completes the questionnaire and uploads its documents on the ESG Cert platform, where it can track the status of its application.
  • The company confirms or corrects its sector and may add or remove material themes. ESG Cert reviews each removal and the accompanying written explanation.
  • Values read from documents or calculated by ESG Cert are shown to the company, which may amend them before confirming all values at submission.
  • Before the rating is issued for the first time, the company is notified and has at least two full working days to report factual errors (Article 15(12) of Regulation (EU) 2024/3005).

2.4 Scientific evidence Annex III 1(e) · DR Art. 4(4)

The methodology is based primarily on regulatory and reporting references and scientific evidence. The ESRS, the CSRD, the SFDR, the EU Taxonomy, the VSME standard for SMEs and the Italian SME–bank Sustainability Dialogue framework guide the choice of themes, questions and required documentation. The sector materiality matrix reflects the assessment of ESG Cert's experts for each ATECO division.

Scientific information is used in external screenings through water stress data from WRI Aqueduct 4.0 and official registers of protected areas. ESG Cert identifies relevant references by monitoring legislation and reviewing the literature and sector analyses. Every change to the themes, questions, documentation requirements or materiality matrix is approved by the Technical-Scientific Committee.

2.5 Use of artificial intelligence Annex III 1(k)

ESG Cert uses an AI model to read documents uploaded by the company and suggest values for its answers. Extracted values are recorded as read from a document. The company may amend them and confirms all values at submission. An ESG Cert analyst checks the answers and documents before the rating is issued.

AI does not award points, establish materiality or determine the rating class. These aspects depend exclusively on the rules defined in section 1.

Limitations and risks. The model may misinterpret a value, fail to detect it or associate it with the wrong question, particularly in scanned documents or non-standard formats. Confirmation by the company and checks by the analyst are intended to identify and correct these errors.

3. Limitations

Annex III, point 1 (m), (q) · DR Art. 5

  • Available information. The rating is based on the answers and documents provided by the company. ESG Cert cannot assess information the company has not provided or documented.
  • Completeness and accuracy. ESG Cert checks that documents are present and cover the reference year. It relies on the truthfulness of their content without auditing it.
  • Timeliness. The data are fixed at submission and relate to the reference year. Subsequent events do not change an issued rating during its 365-day validity period.
  • Sector classification. The materiality assessment is based on the main ATECO code, which may not fully represent a diversified or atypical company. The company may adjust the list of material themes by adding or removing themes.
  • External data. Screenings cover only water stress and proximity to listed protected areas. Their reliability depends on the accuracy of public data and site addresses.
  • No estimates. Missing data are not replaced by estimates, proxy values or statistical assumptions. The absence of required documents reduces the points earned.
  • AI reading. Values extracted by AI may contain errors and require checks by the company and the analyst (section 2.5).
  • Comparability. Ratings issued under different methodology versions or reference years may not be comparable.

4. Organisation

Annex III, point 1 (d), (l), (n)

4.1 Ownership structure Annex III 1(d) · DR Art. 6(2)

ESG Cert S.r.l. is a limited liability company incorporated under Italian law, with its registered office at Via del Gonfalone 3, 20123 Milan (VAT IT 12063010966, LEI 815600CDDCD47C4D9D10). It does not belong to a group and is not controlled, directly or indirectly, by another company. It has no subsidiaries.

4.2 Fees and business model Annex III 1(l) · DR Art. 6(3)

  • Payment model: the rating service is funded by fees paid directly by rated companies or through organisations that bring together requests from multiple companies (issuer-paid model). ESG Cert does not offer subscriptions: its ESG rating revenue comes from fees for the service.
  • How fees are determined: fees are based on objective, predefined criteria: company size, complexity of activities and the amount of information to collect and verify. Applying the same criteria to all companies ensures fair, reasonable, transparent and non-discriminatory fees. The applicable amounts are shown on the platform or in commercial documentation.
  • Other services: ESG Cert does not provide consultancy. Other services, such as training, are covered by separate contracts and invoices. Their fees do not affect the cost of the rating, its methodology or its outcomes.

4.3 Conflicts of interest Annex III 1(n) · DR Art. 6(1)

Main sources of risk

  • The issuer-paid model: the rated company pays for its rating, directly or through organisations that collect rating requests on its behalf.
  • Commercial relationships with rated companies and with organisations that bring together their rating requests.
  • Other services, such as training, provided to rated companies.
  • Analysts' past professional relationships with, or financial interests in, a rated company.
  • External pressure or incentives that could influence the opinion.

Mitigation measures

  • Methodology development, analysis, sales and control are separate functions.
  • Analysts do not sell the service or provide consultancy to rated companies. ESG Cert does not provide consultancy services.
  • Analysts' remuneration is not linked to rating outcomes or the continuation of the client relationship.
  • Information is shared only with those who need it to perform their role. Relevant interactions and decisions are traceable.
  • Analysts declare their interests. Potentially relevant relationships are assessed before each assignment and throughout its duration.
  • Analysts apply the approved rules and cannot change the result at their discretion.
  • If the measures in place are insufficient to prevent or adequately mitigate a conflict, the assignment is not carried out.

For further details, see the ESG Cert Policy (PDF).

5. Complaints and contact Art. 19

For questions about this disclosure or the methodology, or to submit a complaint about a rating, please write to claims@esgcert.eu.

Complaints are handled under procedure P04 Non-conformities, Complaints and Appeals and reviewed by staff independent of the rating concerned. The review outcome, decision and any corrective action are recorded. See also the list of documents in force (PDF).